Cutout cookie dough can be frozen two ways. Both work equally well, so pick the one that you have time for.
Drop cookies and ball cookies can easily be shaped and frozen before being baked.
To thaw drop cookie dough, immediately transfer frozen balls to a baking sheet. Let stand 15 minutes to thaw. Then, bake as the recipe directs.
As the name suggests, icebox cookies freeze well—with the right method, that is!
To bake slice-and-bake cookie dough, cut cookie dough into slices while frozen for best results in keeping a round edge. Place on cookie sheet 1- to 2-inches apart and let stand five minutes, then bake.
Transfer baked cookies to a cooling rack and allow to cool completely.
Once cool, place cookies in a single layer to avoid breakage. Store in flat-bottomed, square or rectangular plastic containers with airtight lids. (Round or shaped containers can cause cookies to bend and break.)
Line the bottom of each container with waxed paper or plastic wrap. Repeat between each layer of cookies, ending with the paper/wrap.
Label the container with cookie type and date frozen.
Keep these tips in mind for best results when freezing decorated cookies.
Ready to test out these tips? Try our Cookies That’ll Keep in the Freezer.